There are separations that arise from an unsustainable cohabitation and others that occur when one spouse falls in love with someone else and decides to start anew elsewhere.
Let's consider two examples.
On one hand, there's a woman who, after suffering abuse, decides to leave the marital home. She does so because staying under the same roof has become impossible.
On the other hand, there's a man who falls in love with another woman, packs his bags, and decides to live with her.
Two very different situations, but both share a common question: does the person who leaves the home lose their rights to the property?
The answer is no. Or at least, not automatically.
Let's start with a fundamental principle: leaving the residence does not mean relinquishing ownership.
If the house is co-owned, each spouse retains their share. If it is registered in the name of only one, it is still necessary to verify the couple's property regime and the manner in which the property was purchased. In a regime of community property, a property acquired during the marriage may belong to both, even if formally registered to only one, except for the exceptions provided by law.
So, what changes when one of the two leaves?
In the case of the woman who leaves because she is a victim of abuse, leaving the home can be fully justified. One cannot expect a person to remain in a dangerous or unsustainable environment to fulfill the duty of cohabitation.
In the case of the man who decides to leave to start a relationship with someone else, the situation may be different.
Unjustified departure from the marital home and infidelity can have consequences in the separation, even in terms of potential fault. However, be cautious: packing bags or falling in love with someone else does not automatically result in fault. It is necessary to assess whether that behavior actually caused the marital crisis or if cohabitation had already become intolerable.
There is another aspect not to be forgotten: the presence of children.
When there are minor children or adult children who are not financially independent living with one of the parents, the judge may assign the enjoyment of the family home to the parent with whom they live, prioritizing their interest.
And this can happen even when the property is exclusively owned by the other spouse.
Note: the assignment of the house does not transfer ownership. The spouse who owns the property continues to hold the title, but may temporarily lose the right to use it due to the judge's decision.
Certainly, owning a house and having the right to live in it are not always the same thing.
So, who is right between the one who stays and the one who leaves?
The law does not award the house as a prize to the more disciplined spouse, nor does it automatically take it away from the one who decides to leave.
Each situation must be evaluated by considering various factors: the ownership of the property, the couple's property regime, the circumstances of the separation, the possible presence of children, and the judge's decisions.
One thing, however, is certain: before leaving a house or thinking you have lost all rights to it, it is always better to seek information and consult a professional.
Because when a marriage ends, the connection to the home where you lived together doesn't always end too.
And to accompany you in your reading, we also recommend a listen: a truly beautiful song by singer-songwriter Daniele Silvestri, "La mia casa."
Martina Di Meo, mdimeo@remax.it
